Nitinol (nickel-titanium alloy, NiTi) is widely used in fields such as orthodontics, endodontics, and medical implants (e.g., vascular stents) due to its exceptional mechanical properties, including superelasticity and shape memory. However, because NiTi contains a high percentage of nickel, its long-term contact with biological tissues raises certain concerns about allergenic and toxic effects. This overview highlights the essential points regarding the biocompatibility and clinical usage of NiTi alloys, discussing factors such as ion release, surface treatments, and comparisons with stainless steel (SS) alloys.
1) NiTi Alloy Composition and Biological Effects
- Basic Components
NiTi is an intermetallic compound composed of roughly 50% nickel and 50% titanium. Nickel is a well-known potential allergen, which poses a risk of hypersensitivity or allergic reactions in susceptible patients. Nonetheless, the amount of nickel released from NiTi is often lower than from other nickel-containing alloys, such as certain types of stainless steel (SS). Research generally indicates that NiTi is safe under typical usage conditions in dentistry and medicine. - Nickel Ion Release
The release of nickel ions from NiTi alloy can increase under acidic conditions (low pH) or mechanical loading. In the oral environment—where pH fluctuations, saliva, and mechanical stresses occur—untreated NiTi or SS wires can show elevated nickel ion release. In high enough concentrations, nickel can cause localized or systemic allergic/inflammatory responses. - Allergy and Hypersensitivity
Nickel is one of the most common allergens worldwide. Patients with prior sensitization (e.g., from jewelry, piercings, or occupational exposure) are at higher risk. Even so, clinically severe nickel allergic reactions related to NiTi wires or stents remain relatively rare. A thorough patient history is essential. If the patient is confirmed or highly suspected of having nickel allergy, low-nickel or nickel-free alternatives (e.g., titanium molybdenum alloy, Ni-free stainless steel) should be considered.
2) Surface Treatments and Corrosion Behavior
- Electropolishing
One of the most effective ways to enhance both corrosion resistance and long-term biocompatibility in NiTi (for orthodontic wires or stents) is electropolishing. This process reduces surface roughness and fosters the formation of a passive oxide layer, significantly diminishing nickel release. Studies have demonstrated that electropolishing can lower nickel release from around 10% down to 0.1% or less. - Oxide Layer and Corrosion
The titanium content in NiTi aids in forming a stable titanium oxide (TiO₂) layer on the surface, which serves as a natural barrier against corrosion. Maintaining the integrity and smoothness of this oxide layer is crucial for minimizing ion release. However, factors such as acidic pH, bacterial metabolites, temperature changes, and mechanical wear can compromise the oxide layer, potentially elevating nickel ion release. - Additional Surface Modifications
Beyond electropolishing, advanced techniques like plasma treatment or laser-based surface texturing can further reduce ion release and enhance the bond strength to adhesives in orthodontic or implant applications. In particular, surface modification in NiTi can improve the retention of retainer adhesives and thus optimize clinical outcomes.
3) Clinical Applications and Key Properties
- Orthodontic Archwires
NiTi is predominantly used in orthodontics to provide low, continuous forces over long distances, making it extremely effective for initial alignment. Its superelastic characteristics help deliver consistent tooth movement and reduce the risk of wire breakage. NiTi archwires often require fewer replacements compared to stainless steel wires. - Fixed Retainers
After active orthodontic treatment, NiTi has been increasingly used for fixed lingual retainers. Recent CAD/CAM technologies (e.g., “Permatter”) allow the production of fully customized NiTi retainers, precisely adapted to the lingual surfaces of the patient’s teeth. When combined with thorough surface treatments (electropolishing, etc.), NiTi retainers exhibit excellent biocompatibility and durability. - Vascular Stents
In cardiovascular surgery, “Nitinol stents” leverage NiTi’s flexibility and resistance to fracture under physiological stresses. The superelastic property enables the stent to maintain patency in blood vessels despite significant mechanical loads. As with orthodontic applications, surface modification (e.g., electropolishing or polymer coating) is commonly performed to minimize corrosion and ion release.
4) Cytotoxicity and Biocompatibility Evaluations
- In Vitro Testing
Numerous in vitro studies use cell culture models (e.g., fibroblasts or epithelial cells) to assess cytotoxic potential. For instance, research from various universities (including studies focusing on NiTi retainer wires) concludes that NiTi generally meets clinical safety thresholds. Samples undergoing advanced surface treatments typically show even lower ion release and negligible cytotoxicity. - Allergenic Potential
Despite being a recognized allergen, nickel’s release from NiTi, when properly processed or treated, is usually minimal in normal clinical conditions. Nonetheless, in confirmed nickel-hypersensitive patients, alternatives such as TMA (titanium-molybdenum alloy) or specialized titanium-based alloys are recommended. - Long-Term Clinical Data
Over several decades of usage, NiTi materials have proven successful in both orthodontic and endovascular treatments. Regular maintenance (e.g., in orthodontic usage, routine retainer checks) and good oral hygiene help ensure that corrosion and nickel release remain minimal.
5) Comparison of NiTi and Stainless Steel (SS)
- Mechanical Properties
- Elasticity and Superelasticity: NiTi surpasses stainless steel in elasticity, maintaining consistent forces over time and distances.
- Fatigue Resistance: NiTi is more resistant to fatigue failure, reducing the likelihood of wire or stent fracture under cyclic loads.
- Ion Release
Both NiTi and SS contain nickel, so an acidic environment combined with mechanical stress may lead to increased nickel release. If NiTi undergoes proper surface modification, nickel release can be brought down to extremely low levels. Conversely, standard SS 316L predominantly contains iron (Fe), posing a potential for iron ion release as well. - Allergic Considerations
Any nickel-containing metal can be problematic for hypersensitive individuals. Both NiTi and SS are relatively safe for the general population, but caution is advised with known nickel-allergic patients. In such cases, truly “Ni-free” steels or titanium alloys may be more suitable. - Clinical Pros and Cons
- Orthodontics: NiTi typically excels for early tooth alignment due to its consistent, light forces and low fatigue failure rate. SS wires are favored for heavier force applications or when a more rigid archwire is required.
- Implants/Stents: Nitinol stents offer superior flexibility and reduced fracture risk, while stainless steel stents tend to be stiffer but can also be used effectively in many vascular scenarios.
6) Conclusions and Recommendations
- Surface Treatments
Where NiTi or SS alloys are intended for long-term use (e.g., fixed retainers, stents), electropolishing significantly enhances corrosion resistance and overall biocompatibility. Maintaining a stable, continuous oxide layer is critical for limiting nickel release. - Allergy Management
Patients with a documented history of nickel hypersensitivity should undergo appropriate testing (patch tests, medical history review) before NiTi or SS devices are used. In confirmed cases, TMA or “Ni-free” titanium alloys can be considered. - Clinical Follow-Up
In orthodontics, regular check-ups are necessary to detect potential issues (e.g., breakage, plaque build-up, or corrosion). Providing detailed oral hygiene instructions helps to control pH and mitigate the risk of corrosion. - Future Technologies
CAD/CAM-generated NiTi retainers, or wires enhanced with plasma, laser texturing, and other advanced surface modifications, promise improved clinical results. NiTi’s superelastic properties and low failure rate ensure that it remains a primary choice for both orthodontic treatments and medical implants.
Overall, NiTi alloy demonstrates excellent mechanical performance and is considered biologically safe, provided it is handled with appropriate surface modifications and patient-specific considerations. With adequate care—particularly in terms of preventing corrosion and managing nickel sensitivity—NiTi remains a high-value material in both orthodontics and medical implantology.
Leave a Reply